About the

APEX WORLD CLASS™ by YATES+ Award

“APEX WORLD CLASS™ by YATES+ is the only award in the world audited by industry professionals — on real flights, in real time — across dimensions that matter most to today’s travellers, with rigorous analysis and peer validation.”

APEX WORLD CLASS™ by YATES+ award was created as a collaboration between APEX, the Airline Passenger Experience Association, and Yates+Partners, an aviation guest experience consultancy, to recognize excellence.

Qualifications for the APEX WORLD CLASS™ by YATES+ award are through a combination of one year’s guest experience ratings, in tandem with extensive audits by industry professionals, rating every aspect of the guest experience over many flights and in every class.

It is the APEX WORLD CLASS™ by YATES+ award’s focus on a wide and relevant array of customer happiness drivers that is raising the bar for aviation.

The recipients of the 2024 APEX WORLD CLASS™ by YATES+ airline and inaugural lounge award were recognized in October 2024.

Insights into the rigor
of APEX WORLD CLASS™ by YATES+

APEX WORLD CLASS™ by YATES+ is considered across extensive, customer-relevant dimensions clustered under three constructs.

APEX WORLD CLASS™ by YATES+  Audit Process

The World’s Only Recognition Program Audited by Industry Professionals
Recognition awarded only to designated score achievers
Real-Time, Experience Based, Qualitative, No checkbox
Annual Audit Program
Actionable Feedback for Performance Improvement, Strategic Planning
Over 1,000 Hours of Audit Analysis Processing
Analyzed across 17 dimensions under 4 audit constructs
Minimum 8 flight sectors for airline audits
Minimum 4 operating sectors for lounge audits
Independent Peer Review, Deliberation & Validation
Peer reviews by Academic and market intelligence experts
Results validation by APEX WORLD CLASS™ by YATES+ committee
NPS & CSAT Triangulation Study
Comprehensive evaluation between experts and consumer insights
Benchmarking with YOY performance and other World Class brands
Executive Analysis and Recommendation Workshop
Minimum 3-hour workshop by YATES+ consultants (key learnings/ opportunities/ gaps)
Full analysis report for internal sharing and continuous improvement

Triangulation and Benchmarking

Net Promoter Score, or NPS, it a leading metric used by companies to measure customer satisfaction and loyalty.  It is calculated by subtracting the percentage of detractors (dissatisfied and highly dissatisfied customers) from the percentage of promoters (highly satisfied customers).

For each flight sector, an NPS score was calculated for both economy class and business class, based on auditor ratings.  These NPS scores were benchmarked against the average NPS score for airlines, a year's worth of airline-provided NPS data for each service class and flight sector, and Best-in-Class APEX audits to enable each airline to see where they shine, and more importantly, detailed, actionable diagnoses of the potential causes of non-best-in-class NPS scores.

  • Farris, P.W., Bendle, N., Pfeifer, P.E. & Reibstein, D. .  (2010).  Marketing Metrics: The Definitive Guide to Measuring Marketing Performance.  Pearson: London
  • see Fisher & Kordupleski (2018); Romaniuk,  Nguyen & East (2011); Keiningham, Cooli, Andreassen & Aksoy (2007); Mecredy, Wright & Feetham (2018); Sharp (2008); Pinitore, Morgan, Rego, Gigliotti & Meyers (2007); Lewis & Mehmet (2019).
  • NICE Satmetrix 2021 Consumer Net Promoter Benchmark Study, available [www.satmetrix.com/nps-benchmarks/]
  • Although the NPS is calculated on a scale of -100 to +100, the general rule that any deviation of less than 5 percentage points  is managerially not actionable has been adopted here  see: Kennedy, Scriven & Nenycz-Theil (2014); Anesbury, Winchester & Kennedy, (2017).
  • See Halvorsrud, Kvale & Følstad (2016).
APEX WORLD CLASS™ by YATES+ auditors observe, score and provide feedback on every touch point during real-time experiences in-flight and in-lounge based on 4 key Constructs
Safety & Well-being
Sustainability
Service-Guest Experience
F&B Execution

Safety & Well-Being

Experience "keep me safe"

The Safety & Well-Being construct is composed of three dimensions — Minimalizing, and Reassuring.

For travelers, health, safety & well-being are top of mind.

Airlines that consistently and seamlessly deliver an onboard experience where safety & well-being are clearly prioritized while still being able to connect warmly with each passenger are entering the world class threshold.

Exceptional performance
2025
2022
2022

SUSTAINABILITY

Experience “care for our environment”

The sustainability construct is composed of seven dimensions — Published Commitments, Digitalization, Weight, Circular Mindset, Active Promotion Good Practices, Materials and Waste.

Addressing environmental impact is a strategic imperative for airlines today. It is no longer sufficient to simply verbalize aspirations, APEX WORLD CLASS™ by YATES+ airlines are publishing their commitments and taking clear and visible actions.

Exceptional performance
2025
2022
2022

SERVICE-GUEST EXPERIENCE

Experience “designed space that comforts, recognizes and engages”

The Service-Guest Experience construct is composed of eight dimensions — Brand Integrity, Comfort, Engagement, Connectivity, Personalisation (Business Class), Thoughtfulness (Premium Economy Class), Attentiveness (Economy Class), and Intensity of Hospitality.   

Airlines that deliver a consistently exemplary guest experience in across all cabin classes — Business, Premium Economy, and Economy — paying attention to critical details to ensure evidence of care and thoughtfulness shine through at every touchpoint, are recognized as APEX WORLD CLASS™ by YATES+.

Exceptional performance
2025
2022
2022

F&B EXECUTION

Experience “carefully crafted and exceptionally prepared F&B offering”

The F&B Execution construct is composed of two dimensions — Food and Beverage.  

Airlines that are able to design and deliver menus that are delicious, healthy, eye appealing and meet the diverse tastes of guests are reaching World Class.

Exceptional performance
2025
2022
2022

Congratulations to the 2025 recipients OF APEX WORLD CLASS™ by YATES+ AWARD

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consetetur sadipscing elitr, sed diam nonumy eirmod tempor invidunt ut labore et dolore magna aliquyam erat, sed diam voluptua. At vero eos et accusam et justo duo dolores et ea rebum. Stet clita kasd gubergren, no sea takimata sanctus es.

Recently Rated

Triangulation and Benchmarking

Net Promoter Score, or NPS, it a leading metric used by companies to measure customer satisfaction and loyalty.  It is calculated by subtracting the percentage of detractors (dissatisfied and highly dissatified customers) from the percentage of promoters (highly satisfied customers).  The average NPS score for airlines in 2021, according to Satmetrix, was 45.

For each flight sector, an NPS score was calculated for both economy class and business class, based on auditor ratings.  These NPS scores were benchmarked against the 2021 average NPS score for airlines, a year's worth of airline-provided NPS data for each service class and flight sector, and Best-in-Class APEX audits to enable each airline to see where they shine, and more importantly, detailed, actionable diagnoses of the potential causes of non-best-in-class NPS scores.

  • Farris, P.W., Bendle, N., Pfeifer, P.E. & Reibstein, D. .  (2010).  Marketing Metrics: The Definitive Guide to Measuring Marketing Performance.  Pearson: London
  • see Fisher & Kordupleski (2018); Romaniuk,  Nguyen & East (2011); Keiningham, Cooli, Andreassen & Aksoy (2007); Mecredy, Wright & Feetham (2018); Sharp (2008); Pinitore, Morgan, Rego, Gigliotti & Meyers (2007); Lewis & Mehmet (2019).
  • NICE Satmetrix 2021 Consumer Net Promoter Benchmark Study, available [www.satmetrix.com/nps-benchmarks/]
  • Although the NPS is calculated on a scale of -100 to +100, the general rule that any deviation of less than 5 percentage points  is managerially not actionable has been adopted here  see: Kennedy, Scriven & Nenycz-Theil (2014); Anesbury, Winchester & Kennedy, (2017).
  • See Halvorsrud, Kvale & Følstad (2016).

FAQ

You can find help through the most frequently asked questions by users or requested assistance.